2019 Recruiting, Hiring, and Job Application Trends
There is a stark difference between how most job seekers prefer to apply for roles and the way most successful applicants end up getting hired.
Looking for a job can be overwhelming - especially if you were recently laid off, are looking for your first job out of college, or aren’t currently employed.
Before you start aggressively sending out copies your resume, let’s stop to consider what strategy is actually the most effective in landing people jobs.
First, we’ll look at what research shows about job seeker application preferences in more detail.
Then, we’ll look at the statistics on how most applicants actually got hired.
You may be surprised by the findings, and hopefully, they encourage you to think twice about your application strategy!
Preferred ways to apply for a job, according to job seekers
According to Glassdoor research, 51% of job seekers say they prefer to find opportunities online, and 35% of candidates say they prefer to apply for positions via their phone.
These statistics make sense, as desktop and mobile are, after all, the easiest and most convenient methods!
Jobvite’s 2019 Recruiting Benchmark Report shares interesting statistics on where job applications actually come from.
Jobvite analyzed over 13 million applications and reported that "from a pure volume perspective, 2019 shows that most applicants still come from career websites and job boards, followed by referrals."
Job boards and career sites accounted for 84.3% of all applications:
- 49.3% of applications came from job boards
- 34.9% of applications came from career sites
Referrals were the third-highest source of applications, making up just 2.63%!
Who actually gets hired
We know that most candidates apply for jobs online, but which applicants end up getting offers?
Is applying to jobs online an effective use of your time?
212,875 of the 13 million applicants Jobvite analyzed were ultimately hired.
Of these 212,875 hires, the following number originally applied via:
- Career Sites - 69,502
- Job Boards - 45,928
- Recruiters - 31,172
- Referrals - 29,458
- Internal Candidates - 19,242
- Hiring Managers - 6,425
However, as Jobvite explains, "looking only at the absolute numbers can be misleading if you are trying to find the most effective source."
The report confirms what we already suspected from anecdotal data:
"The sources that deliver the highest percentage of applicants don’t necessarily translate to the highest percentage of hires. After all, it’s not about the quantity of candidates, but the quality of hires."
Let's simply look at what percentage of applicants from each source were actually hired (the total number of hires divided by total number of applications for each category):
- Hiring Managers - 32.5%
- Internal Candidates - 25.9%
- Recruiters - 14.1%
- Referrals - 7.8%
- Career Sites - 1.4%
- Job Boards - 0.7%
To put these figures into perspective, Harvard's acceptance rate for the class of 2023 was 5.3%.
Your odds of getting into Harvard are higher than your odds of getting a job via a career site or a job board!
What this research means for you
The Jobvite data clearly shows that you are significantly more likely to get hired if you apply for a job through a hiring manager or recruiter at the company.
If you have been applying to jobs online and aren’t hearing back, perhaps it’s time to reconsider your application strategy!
Instead of submitting your application online and passively waiting for a response, why not dig deeper?
Questions to consider include:
- Who is the hiring manager (or leader) of the department that you applied for a job with? Can you find them on LinkedIn and send a quick introduction?
- Who is the internal recruiter at the company dealing with the job posting? Can you find their email address or phone number?
- Do you know anyone who works at the company who may be able to refer you?
Due to the high volume of applications and low hiring rates for candidates who apply online, it's also important to optimize your resume for applicant tracking systems if you plan to do so.
About Resume Pilots
Resume Pilots is an award-winning executive resume writing, career coaching, and outplacement firm. Our previous clients include CEOs and senior executives at the world's leading companies.
Here's how we can help you:
Resume, Cover Letter, and LinkedIn Writing: After a one-hour phone consultation, one of our expert writers will prepare your top-quality personal marketing materials from scratch.
Career Transitions: A powerful combination of our document writing and career coaching services helps position you to secure a new role.
We're a proud member of the Professional Association of Resume Writers and Career Coaches. All of our writers have studied in the Ivy League and other top-tier universities and have solid industry experience.